Monthly Archives: September 2025

Meeting of September 30, 2025

Jim Rhetta on “Would England Have Recognized the South?”

A common belief among Civil War historians is that England was frequently inclined toward diplomatic recognition of the Confederacy. This belief is supported by the view that a shortage of cotton nearly drove England to recognize the South to secure cotton supplies for economic stability and employment in the cotton industry. However, the key missing requirement for diplomatic recognition was a decisive Confederate battlefield victory to convince England that the Confederacy was a militarily viable nation.

Closer evaluations of this issue are often lacking in U.S. publications, with familiar beliefs repeated across generations of readers. This presentation will examine British decision-makers, influencers, foreign policy, and political processes to uncover the truth about England’s intentions regarding recognition of the Confederacy.

Jim Rhetta retired from Lockheed Corporation and also retired as a Colonel in the U.S. Air Force Reserve, serving in the Intelligence Community. In both careers, he monitored, analyzed, and reported on global conflicts and crises for the Department of Defense. His roles required him to write and present daily intelligence briefings, threat assessments, and weekly activity reports. He authored classified books on foreign air defense threats and orders of battle. He continues to monitor current events and historical subjects for their impact on society today.

Quiz for September 30, 2025

Civil War Quiz: What Do You Know About President Lincoln’s Cabinet Secretaries?

Q#1 – Who was President Lincoln’s first Secretary of War?

Q#2 – President Lincoln replaced his first Secretary of War with Edwin M. Stanton. What were the reasons for the replacement?

Q#3 – What two major accomplishments is Secretary of the Navy Gideon Welles known for during the Civil War?

Q#4 – What was the main reason that Lincoln named Caleb B. Smith as his Secretary of the Interior?

Q#5 – What were two major accomplishments Postmaster General Montgomery Blair was known for?

Q#6 – What major legal action by President Lincoln did Attorney General Edward Bates strongly disagree with?

Q#7 – During the Civil War, who was responsible for implementing the National Banking System to help finance the Union cause?

Q#8 – What two major criticisms were directed toward Secretary of War Edwin M. Stanton?

Q#9 – What were the reasons that Secretary of the Interior Caleb B. Smith clashed with President Lincoln’s wife, Mary Todd Lincoln?

Q#10 – What major postal reforms did Postmaster General Blair institute regarding mail delivery?

Q#11 – After President Lincoln was assassinated, which Cabinet Secretary is credited with making the statement, “Now he belongs to the ages”?

Q#12 – Which of President Lincoln’s Cabinet Secretaries was later named Chief Justice of the United States Supreme Court?

Q#13 – What nickname did President Lincoln assign to his Secretary of the Navy, Gideon Welles?

Q#14 – What major reform regarding the federal monetary system is Secretary of the Treasury Salmon P. Chase known for?

Q#15 – Who organized the manhunt for Abraham Lincoln’s assassin, John Wilkes Booth?

Picnic Meeting of September 6, 2025

Tonya McQuade on “Visits to ECW Symposium in Fredericksburg and the Gettysburg Battlefield”

Tonya McQuade will be speaking about her recent attendance at the 11th annual Emerging Civil War Symposium in Fredericksburg, VA, at Stevenson Ridge, Spotsylvania Courthouse, August 1–3. This year’s theme was “The Cities of War,” with keynote speaker Ted Savas presenting Handshakes, Gambling, Gunpowder, and Augusta: How George W. Rains and Jefferson Davis Changed the Course of the American Civil War. Other speakers addressed a variety of topics, including “Confederate Privateering in San Francisco,” “The Richmond Bread Riot of 1863,” “Grant in St. Louis: The Desperate Years,” and “Suffering, Death, and Destitution: Charleston, South Carolina Burned and Shelled.” Tonya will share highlights from the conference and the battlefield tour of Fredericksburg, as well as stories and photos from her first-time visits—with her husband—to both Gettysburg and Fort McHenry after the conference.

Tonya Graham McQuade is the author of A State Divided: The Civil War Letters of James Calaway Hale and Benjamin Petree of Andrew County, Missouri, 1862–65, and is a contributing writer to the Emerging Civil War website. She has a love for both history and historical fiction, as well as a passion for writing, music, travel, and genealogical research.

In the summer of 2023, Tonya visited Ireland and Scotland with her husband, Mike. Her first night in Dublin, she heard a live performance of the ballad “Paddy’s Lament,” and the song planted itself in her brain. She continued to think about the song’s haunting lyrics as she visited Dublin’s EPIC Immigration Museum, viewed the nearby Famine Memorial, and climbed aboard the replica Jeanie Johnston famine ship. Once she returned to San Jose, she began researching the song’s history, listening to its various versions, and studying the Irish experience in the Civil War—particularly as part of the Irish Brigade. She eventually wrote two related articles for the Emerging Civil War website. This presentation expands on those articles.

A long-time English teacher at Los Gatos High School, Tonya lives in San Jose, California. She is an active member of Emerging Civil War, South Bay Civil War Round Table, South Bay Writers/California Writers Club, National League of American Pen Women, and Poetry Center San Jose. You can learn more about Tonya on her website at tonyagrahammcquade.com, where you’ll also find photos related to the book and her research trips to Missouri. You can also find links to her Chasing History and Emerging Civil War blog posts, her poetry and photography, and her social media sites.

Quiz for September 6, 2025

Civil War Quiz: What Do You Know About the Dred Scott Decision?

Q#1 – What was the official name for the Dred Scott Decision?

Q#2 – What error did the U.S. Supreme Court clerk make when creating the trial document that was registered with the Court?

Q#3 – Who was Dred Scott?

Q#4 – Who was Dred Scott’s owner at the time of Scott’s first court filing for freedom in 1847?

Q#5 – What action did Scott attempt that failed, which resulted in him seeking his freedom through the legal system?

Q#6 – What was the reason that Scott lost his first trial, Dred Scott v. Irene Emerson, in Missouri in 1847, where he sued for his freedom and that of his family?

Q#7 – With new lawyers, Scott’s case was heard in St. Louis Circuit Court in January 1850, challenging the ruling that testimony in the previous try was hearsay. What was the verdict in this trial?

Q#8 – In February 1850, Emerson’s defense filed a bill of exceptions, which was certified, setting into motion another appeal to the Missouri Supreme Court. What was the result of that trial?

Q#9 – Who was Dred Scott’s owner at the time of the Supreme Court case?

Q#10 – What was President-elect James Buchanan’s interest in the Supreme Court case?

Q#11 – How many Supreme Court justices voted with the majority in the Dred Scott case?

Q#12 – What did the Supreme Court see as the ‘core issue’ in the Dred Scott case?

Q#13 – What was the primary rationale for the Court’s ruling?

Q#14 – What did the U.S. Supreme Court conclude from extensive review of laws from the original American states that involved the status of Black Americans at the time of the Constitution’s drafting in 1787?

Q#15 – What were the three key conclusions documented by the U.S. Supreme Court’s justices in their dissenting opinion?